I’ve just read your new post:
There are some discrepancies:
Squadhelp commission rates vary from 35% to 15% depending upon the selling price of the domain name.
Many of my domains look like this…
So that 35% needs to change to 37%.
The Listing Fee per domain is a made up figure. Using your figures…
SH - If I buy 100 domains at $9 and SH accepts 20 of them, then I’ve paid $900 to get 20 approved.
Elsewhere - If I submit 100 domains at $1 and get 20 accepted, I buy them at $9 (x 20 = $180 + $100 submission), then I’ve paid $280 to get 20 approved.
(actually this also highlights why a $1 submission fee for domains we’d like to register ourselves for SH would be beneficial to both SH and the seller).
So if we update the figures in your examples to the correct figures, then you’ve highlighted that we are better off elsewhere.
This also doesn’t take into account that a $2,000 sale at SH could be a $300 contest win and $1,700 balance, meaning 10% of the contest fee will be deducted, but we could probably overlook that.